A federal judge ruled Tuesday that union workers from one of the country’s largest freight companies must resolve a dispute with the company over a new attendance policy through arbitration, effectively blocking them from striking.
U.S. District Judge Mark T. Pittman of the Northern Texas District ruled in favor of BNSF Railway, which said in court papers that a strike would deprive shippers of transportation, hurt revenue, threaten the safety of the general public, force other employees out of work and cause immediate and substantial schedule disruptions.
BNSF had asked the federal court to block thousands of union members who help transport agricultural and industrial goods nationwide from striking, arguing that the two unions representing 17,000 workers would be in breach of their obligations because the nature of the dispute was "minor" and it didn't rise to a level that would justify a work stoppage.
Pittman agreed, writing that BNSF had established that implementing the new “attendance standards is ‘arguably justified by the terms of the parties’ collective bargaining agreement’ such that the dispute is minor.”
In a statement, BNSF said it was pleased with the ruling and that the attendance policy would "provide more predictability for our train crews while also providing more reliable crew availability, which is essential to meeting our customers' expectations and the demands posed by an increasingly competitive global supply chain."’
The decision means the company and members of the Brotherhood of Locomotive Engineers and Trainmen and the Transportation Division of the International Association of Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers will head to mediation over a new attendance policy set to go into effect Feb. 1.
The policy is a complicated system that would allow employees to earn and lose points depending on when they work or take off.
"I think it's going to hurt us and take us away from our families. If I can get another job, I would do it," said union member Robert Moore, a freight train conductor based in Winslow, Arizona. "I would say the majority of guys out here feel the same way."
About 17,000 workers — more than half of the 30,000 employees — had threatened to stop working over the policy dispute, which would have disrupted the transportation of goods and commodities across the U.S.
BNSF, which operates more than 30,000 miles of track in 28 states, ships steel, crude oil, ethanol, lumber, sugar, cars, chemicals, wheat, corn and soybeans to thousands of industrial and commercial customers.
It hauled 4 million carloads of industrial products and agricultural commodities in 2020, according to company officials.
Freight workers, in many cases, don't have assigned days off and are typically on call 24 hours a day. The current attendance policy allows union members to have seven days off per month. The new policy, a points-based system, penalizes employees for taking days off, the unions say.
In its lawsuit, BNSF characterized the disagreement as a "minor dispute" over the interpretation of existing rights under its collective bargaining agreements with the unions, which meant the matter must be resolved by negotiation or arbitration, not by striking, according to court records.
The unions claimed the new policy constitutes a unilateral change and a violation of their collective bargaining agreements that could be considered a "major" dispute.
"I hate the policy. We feel unappreciated," said union member Douglas Prather, 37, a freight train engineer based in Temple, Texas. "It's really not a place to be, but you need 30 years to retire, so I'm trying to ride it out."
- Judge rules officials can't use marriage interviews for immigration arrests
- Judge Rules Against Women Seeking Admission To Yale Frats
- Scottish ruling puts pressure on Johnson to recall parliament
- Fearing Espionage, US Weighs Tighter Rules on Chinese Students
- Read the full text of Donald Trump's 2020 State of the Union as he makes his case for re-election, lashing out at 'socialists' and saying: 'The best is yet to come!'
- Full Text: President Donald Trump’s 2020 State of the Union Speech
- READ: President Trump's State of the Union address
- Massive Stop & Shop Strike Raises the Stakes for 2020 Democrats
- Text of President Trump’s 2020 State of the Union address
- UK Parliament approves Brexit bill for departure from European Union on January 31
- Boris Johnson slaps down Michel Barnier saying Britain will NOT obey Brussels rules to get a trade deal - after EU negotiator demands the UK commits to a 'level playing field' and gives access to fishing waters
- Full text of President Trump's first State of the Union address
- Five things to watch in Trump's third State of the Union
- Joe Biden’s Union Pitch Is a Throwback Aimed at White Men
- Brexit trade deal clash: UK and EU begin sparring over rules
- Johnson's advice to Queen on suspending UK Parliament was unlawful, court rules
- Surgical strikes changed the game for India
- How past orders paved way for SC ruling on reservation
- Judge tosses EPA policy that barred agency grantees from serving as science advisers
- White House announces Trump's guests for 2020 State of the Union
|Sticker Decal Sorry I Can’t Hear You Over the Sound of How Awesome I Am Funny5.0★ / check it now at Amazon||Union Jack Flag All Over Print T-Shirt check it now at Amazon||Union Jack Flag All Over Print Unisex T-Shirt check it now at Amazon||Can't Keep Cryin Over You check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over You / Time Out for Me check it now at Amazon||Can't Stop Lovin You / Crossing Over check it now at Amazon||Re-Union: Can't Get the Hell Out of Texas$6.83||We Can't Be Friends / It's Over Now$2.99||Can't Get Over You check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over It check it now at Amazon||Just Can't Get Over You check it now at Amazon||I Can't Get Over You check it now at Amazon||Sorry I Can't Hear You Over the Sound of How Awesome I Am PINBACK BUTTON Pin / Badge3.0★ / check it now at Amazon||I don't want to. I don't have to. You can't make me. I'M RETIRED. Ceramic wall plaques handmade in the USA for over 30 years.4.9★ / $12.95||Greeting Card Christmas "Can't Believe That Christmas Is Over..." check it now at Amazon||I Can't Get Over You to Save My Life check it now at Amazon||Getting Through What You Can't Get Over: Stories, Tips, and Inspiration to Help You Move Past Your Pain into Lasting Freedom4.9★ / $13.39||Notions: Over 50 Great Gadgets You Can't Live Without$22.34||I Can't Get Over It: A Handbook for Trauma Survivors by Aphrodite T. Matsakis (Nov 30 1996) check it now at Amazon||The Guy Can't Cook: Over 350 Fantastic No-Fail Recipes a Guy Can't Be Without$5.27||I Can't Believe It's Not Fattening!: Over 150 Ridiculously Easy Recipes for the Super Busy$5.19||I Can't Get Over It: A Handbook for Trauma Survivors$32.95||How To Get Over That Bitch And Grow Balls They Can't Resist: The Masculine Way To Love Leave And Attract Women3.8★ / $54.33||Unbelievably Good Deals and Great Adventures That You Absolutely Can't Get Unless You're Over 50, 2003-2004$6.43||Out of Range: Why the Constitution Can't End the Battle over Guns (Inalienable Rights) check it now at Amazon||The Contest: You Can't Leave 'Till It's Over check it now at Amazon||I Can't Believe I Did It: Stories from Minnesota, North Dakota, Alaska, and All Over the Place$7.99||Unbelievably Good Deals and Great Adventures That You Absolutely Can't Get Unless You're Over 50 (Unbelievably Good Deals) check it now at Amazon||Oh, But You Can Begin Again! Getting Through What You Can't Get Over check it now at Amazon||The One Who Swears You Can't Start Over (Salmon Poetry,) check it now at Amazon||You Can't Start Over, But You Can Start Today: God's Heart for Men in Recovery check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over You Feat. Joe check it now at Amazon||I Can't Get Over You (with Ann Savoy)$1.29||Can't Get Over You (feat. Daryl Dub I.Z.) check it now at Amazon||Just Can't Get Over You (Album Version)$1.29||I Can't Get Over You (Single Version)$1.29||Can't get over loosin' you check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over You (feat. Ingrea Aberra) check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over (UK Radio Edit) check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over You (Acoustic) check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over Losing You (1995 Digital Remaster) check it now at Amazon||I Still Can't Get Over Loving You check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over Losing You check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over You [Performance Tracks]$4.99||Can'T Cross Over check it now at Amazon||I Can't Get Over Your Best Smile [Explicit] check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over You (Album Version) check it now at Amazon||Can't Get Over Losing You ( Junie Morrison) check it now at Amazon||Rule #4: You Can't Misinterpret a Mistletoe Kiss (The Rules of Love)$14.95||Rule #5: You Can't Trust the Bad Boy (The Rules of Love)$14.95|
BNSF unions can't strike over attendance policy, judge rules have 1465 words, post on www.nbcnews.com at January 26, 2022. This is cached page on USA Breaking News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.